Bombing with Mini drones

Nowt else to do so I browsed eBay ‘Drone Accessories’, well, the first page; there’s loads. There are a lot for DJI MInis of various shapes & sizes, and while I can see the use for some of them, most of them bother me a bit! There are things like searchlights and landing skids, which I’m fairly certain would take Minis well over 250g, and I doubt if many eBay purchasers would be properly aware of the legal implications having bought a drone that ‘doesn’t need a license’ that will flying it in a category that ‘does’.

But the thing that has horrifies me most is the ‘throwers’, or ‘droppers’, which will release a load by remote control. These are marketed as being for dropping flowers at weddings, but are much more likely to be used for delivering drugs to prisons! Even if used for ‘legal’ purposes, they will still take the drone over the weight limit and be, frankly, dangerous! Personally, I would regard a bunch of thorny rose-bombs that could easily have my eye out dropped casually on me as a personal attack! They could, of course, also be used to drop more dangerous items in some misguided prank, like water-bombs or flour bags. You are basically turning your drone into a bomber, weaponising it, and this isn’t the Ukraine…

Can the club do anything to lobby for legislation banning these things being sold to fit to Mini drones? They are practically an open invitation to dangerous, illegal, and anti-social flying, and could easily cause a serious injury, since the pilot will have only a vague semblance of control over where they land, especially if released at a ‘safe’ height in windy conditions! Serious injuries are bad, m’kay…

I would be willing to bet that none of our members would have any truck with such rubbish. Fishermen use them to cast bait, but are presumably suitably registered, so, fair enough, a legitmate and safe use; the only one I’ve seen in action was flying what looked like a Mavic, not Mini.

1 Like

A lot of assumptions about other people’s motives, intentions and character there…

I’ve no problem with prohibiting certain items when evidence shows they’re causing disproportionate harm (certain knives, class A drugs, etc). But until that evidence exists, banning drone payload devices because you assume they’ll only be used illegally/antisocially isn’t far removed from banning drones because you can’t imagine any other use than spying on people sunbathing in their back gardens.

Not my cup of tea, but there does seem to be growing subset of anglers using drones to drop bait and lines. I’ve read a few articles about conservation teams using drones to scatter seed for a wider and more natural dispersal.

Talking of a wider dispersal…

3 Likes

Yeah; I wouldn’t want to be downwind of that! And your point about assuming all drone flyers want to perve on people sunbathing is all too valid! Perhaps, in my horror, my reaction was a bit knee-jerk…

The point I was making about accessories in general was that a sub250g drone cannot be legally flown in the sub250g category with any of these attachments fitted to it, and I think it is very unlikely that a) the huge majority of those who buy them are going to be aware of this, or be particularly bothered about it if they were, and, yes, this is an assumption on my part but I think it is a pretty accurate one! Some people may be taking their drones over the weight limit in the belief that the extra lights or propguards are making them safer! Your point about

The point about droppers is that I reckon there is a good case for deciding that they are inherently dangerous on several levels; they will be used to drop stuff on to people, this is encouraged by the marketing, they will affect drone (especailly Mini) performance dangerously especially if they are overloaded (and they will be), and there is enormous potential for them being used with the Mini drones they are specifically designed for in an ant-social, dangerous, and illegal way. They are almost bound to be used for taking drugs into prisons. Trust me, if me or anyone I know (well, most of 'em) are injured or worse by one of these things and I know who piloted it, I’m coming after you with a fat claim for compo!

I made the point about bait-casting because it is a legitimate and safe use of drones, though perhaps not Mini drones. I’ll admit I’m not sure about how you would go about banning the use of droppers in a way that prevented their safe and legitimate use, but the way these things are presented to potential buyers is not consistent with that sort of flying anyway. As I understand the law at present, anyone able to legally fly a 250g+ drone can fly with one of these so long as the payload+drone does not exceed the (I think) 1kg limit and the combination is flown within the parameters of the Drone Code.

That said, DJI do not authorise their drones to carry extra loads, and the Drone Code prohibits dropping items from drones; not sure how the fishermen get around this!

I did look at such devices with an idea for a bit of fun at a Big Meet, drop a small flower bomb closest to a target (some thing, not someone…)
but swapping between drones could be fiddly and would only allow Mini 4 pro owners to take part, as thats the one I would have bought.

1 Like

I prefer to have a little more faith in my fellow flyers.

Of course there will be some who don’t know (or care) that attaching heavy things to their <250g drone will take it in to the next category, but I very much doubt they will be in the majority (and certainly won’t be a huge majority).

I can’t imagine many of them went out and spent £100s on their drone without having a Google about it, and they’d be hard pressed to find a review of a sub-250g drone that doesn’t contain an explanation of why that’s an important number.

And with the minority who didn’t, or just don’t care, I think focussing on whether they might attach a dropper and take their drone over 250g is massively missing the point. The real problem is that if they don’t know/care about the weight then it’s likely that they don’t know/care about any of the rules and they’ll be the ones flying BVLOS, over a crowd, in a field next to an airport.

1 Like

Going over 250g is only a legal issue if you are near to people or buildings. The law does forbid dropping things from drones, though dropping rose petals at a wedding seems reasonable to me.
Does anyone know if this restriction still applies if flying on private property ?

The restriction is part of the Air Navigation Order, it doesn’t matter who owns the piece of land you’re flying over.

2 Likes

Isn’t it a regulation in the Drone Code that items must not be dropped from drones (at least in the leisure category)? Not that anyone planning to break the law will care about that, or flight restrictions generally, but it should close down the argument as to whether these devices are strictly legal, however much fun (or not) they might be.

Only in the Open category. It’s permitted under Article 16, which gives a “… so as …” caveat:

The remote pilot must not cause or permit any article or animal to be dropped from an unmanned aircraft so as to endanger persons or property.

Nothing about endangering the animal being dropped .. but wtf? Who would ever drop an animal, anyway! :exploding_head:

2 Likes

That’s interesting, thank you.

I am sorry I do not agree on banning such things. The reason being drones are often used on farms for good reasons and legitimate but probably not the mini series of drone. But is this a bit like making cars where the speed is restricted? I know Volvo do put an upper limit on their vehicles but still above the UK limits.
As someone else suggested unless it become a real problem it is not really needed to regulate for the sake of regulation imho.
As for drug drops over prisions they could tackle this with jammers perhaps? if they really wanted to prevent such events??? (I’m guessing).
I do however understand where you are coming from though.

Yes, I agree now that lobbying to ban these dropper devices was a knee-jerk reaction and would be impracticable and undesireable in practice. The thing to do ideally would be to somehow prevent their sale on eBay, and restrict it to fishing/farming/other ‘legitimate’ outlets; nobody ever gets booked for being a few grams over the limit anyway, do they? Fat chance of anything like that ever happening, Chinese manufacturers of less repute than DJI will continue to knock these things out on eBay and Temu…

Flying over the weight limit is illegal unless you are registered for Cat.2 and flying within those rules. I would imagine anyone who crashed or lost their drone in such circumstances would find it difficult to claim under Care Refresh!

The world is a terrible and wicked place, get used to it Johnster! I am by nature a law-abiding observer of rules, and get upset when others are not. I get upset a lot…

1 Like

Likewise. I even did A2 CofC just in case my mini 4 pro went overweight with reflective strips and metal Op id for europe and Uk op id sticker!!!

I guess a domestic animal is legally property as would be farm animals. An interesting point though!

Sounds like someone doesn’t know about the A3 category.

1 Like

I have seen videos where thermal drones have been used to find dogs, and also drop treats for the dog to follow out of an incoming tide, also some have microphones so the owner can call the dog also to encourage the dog. But most things can be exploited, look at vhs when you could record things, then dvd-r etc, even portable storage, can now be smuggled into prisions etc, and to be honest their has been cases when prison officers have been caught doing this. Yes you can ban these and ruin it for everyone just like the way the new online safety act is doing to protect kids, which it is not, if you ban the bbc maybe that will save children, for example hue edwards etc, also who was in charge of the cps at the time of jimmy savile, kier starmer, so you can never stop illegal things happening, but if people where more encourage to report these things and know it will be investigated or not brushed asside due to who may be involved that might help

Guernsey have been doing for a number of years… Clearly no other Prison in the UK is following their lead.

2 Likes

Thanks Helpful to know.

I believe there is a reluctance to use jammers in case of injury (or worse) to people going about their lawfal business in the vicinity of the prison. Many prisons are in densely-populated urban locations with busy main roads running close to them. Somewhere like Dartmoor might be more amenable to it, though…

Netting, in my view, would be a better option, but of course it would need maintaining and probably replacing every time there’s a bit of wind; too much like hard work for the authorities! It does seem to me that there is a lot of public media hand-wringing about this issue, but that the authorities seem reluctant to do much about it, which leads me to suspect another agenda is in play here. We know that corrupt prison officers make money by taking contraband in, so the system is not exactly what you’d call sqeaky-clean…