Digital FPV.....DJI vs HDZero vs Orqa vs Walksnail vs openhd.....?

DJI are missing out on a potentially large audience, meaning those of us whom already own goggles that are more HD capable than the DJI Goggles.

I personally will not buy a goggle that only works with one proprietary system. I know you can mod the DJI goggles to work with analog receivers but this is a compromise and not a feature. My Sky04X’s have better optics, better screens, and are far more comfortable than the DJI Goggle. Currently they work on analog, HDZero, Connex Prosight, 3DR Solo, and are great as a surround sound Cinema Goggle. No doubt they will work with other HD systems, as and when they become available.

I don’t believe DJI released the HD system to further enhance and progress the FPV hobby, but rather they did it because they could. Add to that currently the DJI system does not play nice with other technologies due to the large bandwidths it uses and the bidirectional link. That’s why you won’t see DJI involved in the major FPV racing leagues. I believe that Mult-GP are currently trialing SharkByte as an alternative to analog.

I would use the DJI system if/when I acquire the DJI FPV Drone, but for current FPV builds they’ll remain on analog, my future FPV builds will more than likely be SharkByte/HDZero.

2 Likes

They’re simply just apple but for drones. They sell horrendously expensive versions of kit that come in a fancy shell and set it up to not be compatible with anything other than their horrendously expensive parts. Anti consumer bullshit at its finest and the drones of soy farting mongs lap it up :man_shrugging:

yawn

Where as Apple are continuously trying to out do the Android manufacturers, DJI do not have any real competition of which to speak of in the consumer drone market. Yes you do see YouTube videos with titles such as “Is this a Mavic (n) killer”, but this is really just click bait. The proof is in this forum alone. Other than myself, and I openly admit I’m not normal, how many other members have chosen an alternative drone over a DJI product? DJI do make very good drones, each a leader in their class, but I have slammed their FPV system and their FPV drone, but that’s because I am not their target audience.

When you compare the cost of their first off the shelf drone, the Phantom 1, and add to that the cost of equipping it for videography, todays DJI drones are pretty good value. Back then the Phantom 1 was £379, for that you got a drone, a basic controller, and 1 generic 3s 2200mAh battery. To make it video capable you had to add a GoPro3, a minimum of a 2axis Gimbal, a video transmission system, and a video receiver system. By the time this extra gear was added you’d be hard pushed to have any change left from £1000. Today you can get all this, and exponentially more in a DJI Drone costing less than the original Phantom alone.

But back to the DJI FPV versus SharkByte.

If you discount earlier attempts of bringing HD to the FPV community, DJI were the first to offer a reliable, and more importantly repeatable, solution to the masses. And in fairness quite a good solution. And because DJI were top dog (because there were no other dogs) they could charge a premium safe in the knowledge it would sell. However their system still has many short comings which other manufacturers are now taking advantage of. Things like latency, global shutter versus rolling shutter, greater integration, price, etc.

And all of this is beginning to pay off. Take the very recent release of upgraded HDZero cameras. Even the manufacturers of these cameras were sceptical about the success of HDZero capable cameras. So much so that Carl Zhou, the owner and developer of HDZero, had to use his own money to have the cameras manufactured. Runcam have now been forced to eat their own hat as every time a batch is offered for sale they have sold out in less than two minutes.

At this point, if DJI are serious about remaining in the HD market they should be very scared. If they are not concerned then this is a tell tale sign that their current HD system is very close to its End Of Life. Maybe DJI will come out with a new system that can compete with the strengths of a HDZero system while at the same time offering other benefits. But this will most likely result in a system that has no backward compatibility and thus require the customer to reinvest if they wish to remain current. Not too dissimilar to their current camera drone demographic.

4 Likes

If DJI were to bring out a module to fit on all goggles, They’d sell well I reckon. I’d get one. The dji image is definitely better. You could just then pick and choose what module to run as they would be far cheaper that a set of goggles.

2 Likes

Image quality is a bit better but id take losing image quality with signal over slow downs every single day of the week, you can still fly with one, you lose your drone with t’other.

Back in stock.

1 Like

2 Likes

I wonder if DJI/Caddx will ever produce an air unit & goggles with Ocusync 3.0 :thinking:

@DeanoG60 just found £300 in the bank

Nope sadly not.

Really… :anguished: :anguished:

1 Like

One thing I have noticed in the few flights I’ve now done with SB is that my goggle battery drains noticeably faster. I guess this makes sense as the battery is powering both the goggles and HD module. Its not a problem as I have 2 fatshark battery packs. As a comparison if I flew all 6 of my batteries on my analogue quad the fatshark battery would have 2 leds of power left. When I flew 5 batteries on SB I had 1 led of power left. Next time I will charge both fatshark batteries just incase :+1:t2:

As a side note my new HDZero micro cam has been shipped :ok_man: not sure how long it will take to get here but at least its on its way :grin:

1 Like

Same with my DJI goggles running the digi adapter with rapid fire module. Battery drains a hell of a lot quicker.

2 Likes

Yeah they stink mate.

1 Like

Yeah I guess it’s because they are powering 2 devices at once. Not a big problem though

1 Like

New Shark Byte sw available. Fixes some bugs. Needed for the new camera

@SirGunner not sure if you have tried these?

1 Like

Cheers mate I’ll take a look, I have got the premium version of Power Director and that doesn’t like .ts files lol