Using a DJI Mini 2 as an example, looking at the CAA regulations as follows:
“You must be able to see your drone or model aircraft without using:”
“electronic viewing equipment, such as a smart phone, tablet or video goggles”
and the max VLOS seems to be about 500 metres.
Therefore a drone operator cannot fly more than 500m HORIZONTALLY from his/her location even if using the drone’s cam and the video that is fed back to the smartphone (or controller with a display).
I’m looking to verify this because I often see videos of drone range tests on YouTube where the operator is flying the drone some miles away. Admittedly a lot of these are in the US and elsewhere where the rules are presumably different but some are in the UK. So I guess the latter operators are breaking the law and advertising the fact? (no, not looking to name and shame, just want to verify my understanding).
Unless you have spotters along the route so at least one of them can see it at all times, and in direct contact with the pilot. That won’t be the case with nearly all the videos you’ve seen.
And even that is not permitted under the standard regulations: EVLOS requires an additional Operational Authorisation.
Short answer is yes, all the range tests seen on YouTube are likely be illegal under current UK drone regulations.
Longer answer is that the actual legal definition of VLOS under the regulations is a bit worider than what you find on the CAA website (google CAP1789A if you want to check it):
‘visual line of sight operation’ (VLOS) means a type of UAS operation in which, the remote pilot is able to maintain continuous unaided visual contact with the unmanned aircraft, allowing the remote pilot to control the flight path of the unmanned aircraft in relation to other aircraft, people and obstacles for the purpose of avoiding collisions
From my interpretation of what CAA have said about range of VLOS, 500m is a guideline they generally look at but isn’t a hard and fast rule. It comes more down to questions like the size of the drone (a larger drone will have a farther VLOS distance). And simply seeing a dot in a the distance isn’t technically VLOS - you need to be able to determine the orientation of the drone and its approximate position relative to obstacles/hazards without reference to the camera feed.
A suggestion I’d make for extending the effective VLOS of a drone like the Mini 2 is to put fluorescent decals on the arms of the aircraft, of different colours on each arm. That way you can determine the orientation at range a lot more effectively, and it also helps to highlight it against the sky.
A suggestion I got from another thread is reflective tape. I bought silver, put on the body sides and arms. Fairly easy to see in sunlight by rotating the drone, one of the strips usually catches the light.